Further to our recent blog on the challenges facing insolvency practitioners (ISPs) in the current business climate, it now seems that the corporate insolvency market is to be the subject of an Office of Fair Trading (OFT) enquiry .
Some of you will find it hard to have any sympathy for these under fire ISPs, reasoning that as they must be so rushed off their feet at present, a squeeze on their fees would not seem out of order. However it is not all sweetness and light in the world of insolvency. Yes, there may be rich pickings at the top end of the scale, which deserve to be scrutinised (Lehman Brothers anybody?) but at the lower end the picture is much less rosy. Due to the reluctance of the banks and HMRC, the two organisations most likely to put a business into insolvency, to pull the plug on businesses, ISPs, while busy, are not that busy.
Also, as so many businesses now operate on a virtual basis, there are very few, if any, realisable assets available. These barely cover the costs of insolvency never mind leave anything left to pay out to creditors.
I still have my doubts about the way the Woolworths administration was handled, but somebody has to clear up the mess that poorly managed businesses leave behind, and in that regard the insolvency profession in general still does a pretty good job.
Showing posts with label woolworths. Show all posts
Showing posts with label woolworths. Show all posts
Monday, 30 November 2009
Thursday, 19 November 2009
The wonder of a Woolworths administration – part two
Rumblings persist concerning the way that the administration of Woolworths was handled, something that we raised in our blog back in December 2008. Indeed Woolworth’s former management have now added their voices to those who believe that more efforts could have been made by the administrators, Deloittes, to keep the giant store group afloat questioning whether there was a conflict of interest in their provision of advice to the company’s banking syndicate prior to their appointment as administrators. Not surprisingly Deloittes have robustly defended their actions, pointing out that the business simply ran out of money, and that they had been called in with the management’s blessing.
Nobody is pretending that Woolworths was the best run company in the world. However the negative impact of its closure on many high streets up and down the country, and the fact that newly established imitators such as Alworths and Wellworths have seemingly thrived, indicate that the general public placed more value on Woolworths than the financial community apparently did.
With an upsurge in insolvencies expected in 2010, insolvency practitioners will face even more challenges in deciding how terminal the decline of such businesses is, and how far they can go in keeping them alive, whilst not being seen to reward poor management. I wish them all the luck in the world – they are going to need it.
Nobody is pretending that Woolworths was the best run company in the world. However the negative impact of its closure on many high streets up and down the country, and the fact that newly established imitators such as Alworths and Wellworths have seemingly thrived, indicate that the general public placed more value on Woolworths than the financial community apparently did.
With an upsurge in insolvencies expected in 2010, insolvency practitioners will face even more challenges in deciding how terminal the decline of such businesses is, and how far they can go in keeping them alive, whilst not being seen to reward poor management. I wish them all the luck in the world – they are going to need it.
Tuesday, 3 March 2009
Look after your suppliers? No really - look after your suppliers….
The announcement that Zavvi, the music, games and DVD retailer is to close down for good, has brought home a salient point about the recession that often gets overlooked in those “top tips on surviving the recession” listings.
Nearly everybody will suggest that you imagine a scenario when one of your top customers goes bust, but very little emphasis is put on the situation when one of your main suppliers goes the same way. Yet that is precisely what has happened in this case, where the key supplier in question was Entertainment UK, which was a casualty of the Woolworths demise. Not only did Zavvi lose its key supplier at a time when it desperately needed stock i.e. the run up to Christmas, but more importantly it lost valuable credit facilities, which could not be replaced as new suppliers demanded immediate payment.
A salutary lesson for everybody - when your key supplier goes down not only do you lose products that you need for your business, you potentially lose a valuable source of finance. One to add to those key financial relationships that have to be managed.
Nearly everybody will suggest that you imagine a scenario when one of your top customers goes bust, but very little emphasis is put on the situation when one of your main suppliers goes the same way. Yet that is precisely what has happened in this case, where the key supplier in question was Entertainment UK, which was a casualty of the Woolworths demise. Not only did Zavvi lose its key supplier at a time when it desperately needed stock i.e. the run up to Christmas, but more importantly it lost valuable credit facilities, which could not be replaced as new suppliers demanded immediate payment.
A salutary lesson for everybody - when your key supplier goes down not only do you lose products that you need for your business, you potentially lose a valuable source of finance. One to add to those key financial relationships that have to be managed.
Look after your suppliers? No really - look after your suppliers….
The announcement that Zavvi, the music, games and DVD retailer is to close down for good, has brought home a salient point about the recession that often gets overlooked in those “top tips on surviving the recession” listings.
Nearly everybody will suggest that you imagine a scenario when one of your top customers goes bust, but very little emphasis is put on the situation when one of your main suppliers goes the same way. Yet that is precisely what has happened in this case, where the key supplier in question was Entertainment UK, which was a casualty of the Woolworths demise. Not only did Zavvi lose its key supplier at a time when it desperately needed stock i.e. the run up to Christmas, but more importantly it lost valuable credit facilities, which could not be replaced as new suppliers demanded immediate payment.
A salutary lesson for everybody - when your key supplier goes down not only do you lose products that you need for your business, you potentially lose a valuable source of finance. One to add to those key financial relationships that have to be managed.
Nearly everybody will suggest that you imagine a scenario when one of your top customers goes bust, but very little emphasis is put on the situation when one of your main suppliers goes the same way. Yet that is precisely what has happened in this case, where the key supplier in question was Entertainment UK, which was a casualty of the Woolworths demise. Not only did Zavvi lose its key supplier at a time when it desperately needed stock i.e. the run up to Christmas, but more importantly it lost valuable credit facilities, which could not be replaced as new suppliers demanded immediate payment.
A salutary lesson for everybody - when your key supplier goes down not only do you lose products that you need for your business, you potentially lose a valuable source of finance. One to add to those key financial relationships that have to be managed.
I've got the brains, you've got the looks....
Wednesday 21 Jan 09 - Back in the 80s the Pet Shop Boys banged on that "There's a lot of opportunities, if you know when to take them, if there aren't, you can make them".
It is easy to think at the moment that opportunities are in short supply but talking to Henry Camilleri of independent financial advisors Camilleri Associates this morning at a breakfast seminar organised by Clydesdale Bank, it was interesting to hear that he has used the current wave of redundancies by major insurance and investment firms to increase his network of experienced financial advisors. As he said, the chance to bring on board some highly talented people that would not normally be available to him was too good to pass up, and has enabled him to add some weight to the strategy that he has set out for himself to improve his business in 2009. This was one of the points we made in our recent SMART presentation so it was good to hear of a practical example.
The topic today’s seminar was 'Doing business in a slowing economy' with Terry Irwin of TCii Strategic and Management Consultants, a common enough theme perhaps, but the point that companies need to get back to the basics of financial management in order to survive and thrive in the current market bears repeating again and again. Our hosts Clydesdale Bank also made this point in relation to the fact that their parent company National Australia Bank is currently one of the few banks that is relatively unscathed by the current banking turmoil. Terry Irwin believes that we should hit the bottom of this recession during 2009, with some small signs of recovery starting at the end of 2009 or beginning of 2010. Given the speed that the economy is unravelling, I would agree with his assessment about reaching the bottom, but would suggest that businesses adopt the advice of the Pet Shop Boys regarding opportunities in order to plot their own course to recovery outside of any general economic improvement. Henry’s actions above are good start along this road.
It is easy to think at the moment that opportunities are in short supply but talking to Henry Camilleri of independent financial advisors Camilleri Associates this morning at a breakfast seminar organised by Clydesdale Bank, it was interesting to hear that he has used the current wave of redundancies by major insurance and investment firms to increase his network of experienced financial advisors. As he said, the chance to bring on board some highly talented people that would not normally be available to him was too good to pass up, and has enabled him to add some weight to the strategy that he has set out for himself to improve his business in 2009. This was one of the points we made in our recent SMART presentation so it was good to hear of a practical example.
The topic today’s seminar was 'Doing business in a slowing economy' with Terry Irwin of TCii Strategic and Management Consultants, a common enough theme perhaps, but the point that companies need to get back to the basics of financial management in order to survive and thrive in the current market bears repeating again and again. Our hosts Clydesdale Bank also made this point in relation to the fact that their parent company National Australia Bank is currently one of the few banks that is relatively unscathed by the current banking turmoil. Terry Irwin believes that we should hit the bottom of this recession during 2009, with some small signs of recovery starting at the end of 2009 or beginning of 2010. Given the speed that the economy is unravelling, I would agree with his assessment about reaching the bottom, but would suggest that businesses adopt the advice of the Pet Shop Boys regarding opportunities in order to plot their own course to recovery outside of any general economic improvement. Henry’s actions above are good start along this road.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
